Class: Premium Sporty/Performance Cars
Miles Driven: 235
Fuel Used: 11.8 gallons
| CG Report Card | |
|---|---|
| Room and Comfort | B |
| Power and Performance | A |
| Fit and Finish | B+ |
| Fuel Economy | C+ |
| Value | B |
| Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide's impressions of the entire model lineup. | |
| Big & Tall Comfort | |
| Big Guy | B- |
| Tall Guy | B |
| Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. "Big" rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, "Tall" rating based on 6'6"-tall male tester. | |
| Drivetrain | |
| Engine Specs | 405-hp 3.0L |
| Engine Type | Turbocharged 6-cyl |
| Transmission | 7-speed automatic |
| Drive Wheels | Rear-wheel drive |
Real-world fuel economy: 20.0
Driving mix: 50% city, 50% highway
EPA-estimated fuel economy: 17 city/23 highway/19 combined
Fuel type: Premium
Base price: $58,900 (not including $995 destination charge)
Options on test car: Sunset Orange Metallic paint ($550), M double-clutch automatic transmission ($2900), M Driver’s Package ($2500)
Price as tested: $67,045
Quick Hits
The great: Acceleration, handling, general sporty feel, outward visibility
The good: Passenger room (for a sports coupe), cargo space and versatility, friendly control layout, sporty exhaust note
The not so good: Ride quality, price reflects the overall goodness
CG Says:
BMW built its reputation on performance, and our test M2 backed that up. Yet for a (very) sporty coupe, it also proved surprisingly livable and even … dare I say … practical.
Since performance (and economy, for that matter) benefits from lighter weight, a car that’s no bigger and heavier than you need is going to give you the best bang for your buck. And the M2 is tidy, to be sure. Its 176-inch overall length contributes to a curb weight of just 3450 lbs, something that allows its twin-turbo, 405-hp inline six to feel more like a very potent V8. Nail the gas from a stop, and the M2 moves out briskly, then suddenly quickens its pace as the turbos spool up. The dual-clutch 7-speed automatic transmission (a $2900 option to the standard 6-speed manual) rips through shifts as the engine sings its joyous straight-six song, and kicks down fairly quickly when stabbing the throttle prompts a downshift from speed. BMW claims a 4.2-second 0-60 time, which we find entirely believable. But as opposed to some V8 pony cars, this is not a burnout king; turning off the traction control and nailing the gas didn’t produce any wheelspin theatrics (the M2 rightfully snubbing such adolescent behavior), and with only the rear wheels driving the car, it probably puts as much power to the ground as traction would allow.
As might be expected, handling is a strength. Small size and light weight help here, too, with the M2 feeling very nimble and eager in corners. Also as might be expected, this comes at the expense of ride quality, the usual tradeoff when stiff springs and rubber-band tires meet any kind of road irregularity. But the surprise was that smaller bumps – usually a problem for low-profile tires to absorb – were more heard than felt, though larger ones indeed were … felt. Note, however, that this was in Comfort mode, though Sport and even Sport + weren’t brutally stiff. Even in normal urban areas, we’d call the ride “acceptable” for a sport coupe; only in places like Chicago would it likely cause the occasional grimace, though we’d advise against driving one in Detroit without a wheel insurance policy — and a mouth guard.
Otherwise, the M2 Competition provides a nice “daily driver” environment. While BMW took it on the chin after introducing its infamous iDrive control layout more than 15 years ago, a couple of things have combined since to make it more acceptable. Not only has the design logic been upgraded over the years to become much easier to decipher and use, but the concept itself has since been widely adopted by other makes, many in a notably worse fashion. The infotainment system includes a volume knob and eight programmable buttons on the dash, with other adjustments being made through a console control knob with some being redundant on the touchscreen. Climate controls were very easy to reach and use. So overall, the M2’s control layout actually ranks as “pretty good” now.
Also “pretty good” are the M2’s accommodations. Visibility borders on excellent all around, though the sunvisors unfortunately don’t extend when swung to the sides, leaving lots of the windows uncovered.
Our tester had the $2900 M Driver’s Package, which included sport seats with adjustable lumbar and side support along with heat and memory that were – to me, at least – very comfortable. Most touch surfaces are thinly padded with what at least looked like leather, and some others boasted sporty carbon-fiber panels.
Test Drive: 2018 Infiniti Q60 Red Sport
As common on performance vehicles, cabin storage was marginal, though better here than in some competitors. A small glovebox is joined by a small console box with USB port, two covered cupholders next to another USB and a 12-volt outlet, a shallow front console tray, and large map pockets in the doors.
Even tall drivers should find plenty of stretch-out room, though using legroom to its fullest makes the rear seat uninhabitable to humans; behind a normal-size driver, however, it managed to hold my 5’9 frame in relative comfort, though that’s about the max. Getting back there was a little easier than in many coupes thanks to a power-sliding front seat and a relatively tall, wide opening, but like most other coupes, the seat only holds two passengers.
The cargo area is a highlight. Besides being wide at the rear and decently sized, the strut-type trunklid hinges don’t intrude on the cargo area, and the rear seat backs fold level with the cargo floor — both being unusual and appreciated features — with the only demerit being that the floor isn’t completely flat through its width.
Test Drive: 2019 Dodge Challenger R/T Scat Pack Plus Wide Body
Quick Spin: 2018 Ford Mustang GT
Certainly there are V8 pony cars that could match the M2 in a straight line and possibly on a road course, but few carry anything close to the BMW’s overall esteem. The company’s M-Series vehicles are the stuff of legend, and this smallest, lightest, and least expensive of the breed does nothing to tarnish that image.
Check out our Premium Sporty/Performance Car Best Buys
Listen to the very entertaining Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast
