Class: Compact Pickup
Miles driven: 170
Fuel used: 10.8 gallons
| CG Report Card | |
|---|---|
| Room and Comfort | C+ |
| Power and Performance | B |
| Fit and Finish | C+ |
| Fuel Economy | B- |
| Value | B- |
| Report-card grades are derived from a consensus of test-driver evaluations. All grades are versus other vehicles in the same class. Value grade is for specific trim level evaluated, and may not reflect Consumer Guide's impressions of the entire model lineup. | |
| Big & Tall Comfort | |
| Big Guy | B |
| Tall Guy | B |
| Big & Tall comfort ratings are for front seats only. "Big" rating based on male tester weighing approximately 350 pounds, "Tall" rating based on 6'6"-tall male tester. | |
| Drivetrain | |
| Engine Specs | 310-hp 3.8-liter |
| Engine Type | V6 |
| Transmission | 9-speed automatic |
| Drive Wheels | 4WD |
Real-world fuel economy: 15.7 mpg
Driving mix: 60% city, 40% highway
EPA-estimated fuel economy: 15/21/17 (city/highway/combined)
Fuel type: Regular gas
Base price: $37,490 (not including $1095 destination charge)
Options on test vehicle: none
Price as tested: $38,585
Quick Hits
The great: Peppy new V6 engine; competitive pricing with a decent amount of standard equipment
The good: Simple, straightforward control layout; off-road capabilities of PRO-4X model
The not so good: Basic design is 15 years old; smaller rear-seat area than some class competitors; jittery ride; lots of hard plastic in the interior
More Frontier price and availability information
John Biel
We won’t say it’s old, but the Nissan Frontier compact pickup currently on the market could serve as its own retro special edition. The 2020 truck is fundamentally the 2005 model as visually refreshed for 2009. Yeah, 2009.
Of course, in all that time the Frontier was improved as much as was practical for what had been the bargain buy in a vehicle class that nearly evaporated before staging a strong comeback in the last couple of years. Even now, on the eve of a next-generation Frontier (which is slated to arrive as a 2021 model), it gets a completely new powerteam and some added standard equipment.
Consumer Guide tried out the new 3.8-liter V6/9-speed automatic Frontier in an off-road-oriented PRO-4X Crew Cab. With the SL trim cut from the line—S and SV models remain—the PRO-4X sits atop the price hierarchy in 2020, starting at $38,595 with delivery. That‘s an increase of about $4500 from ’19, mostly attributable to the change in engine and transmission and the addition of a leather-covered shifter knob and push-button starting as standard equipment. (The base S, which gets all those features plus a manual tilt steering wheel, power windows, and power door locks with driver-side auto-down, jumps approximately $7800 to $27,885 for the price-leader rear-wheel-drive King Cab.)
Test Drive: 2020 Nissan Titan PRO-4X Crew Cab
The 3.8 V6 with automatic is the only way to go in 2020. The engine replaces both a 152-horsepower 2.5-liter 4-cylinder and a 261-horse 4.0-liter V6. The trans steps in for the formerly used 5- and 6-speed manuals and a 5-speed automatic. Despite its smaller displacement, the 310-horsepower 3.8 makes nearly 20 percent more power than the old V6 thanks to direct injection and new cylinder heads with integrated exhaust manifold. (However, maximum torque is unchanged at 281 lb-ft.) The new powerteam makes this a pretty quick and responsive truck that’s really eager off the line, and acceptably quiet.
The additional go should go further, too. EPA fuel-economy estimates are slightly increased for the ’20 Frontier. Models with the part-time 4-wheel drive that’s standard on the PRO-4X are tagged for 17 mpg in the city, 23 mpg on the highway, and 19 mpg combined. Still, this driver averaged just 16.5 mpg after covering 59 miles, 45 percent of which was in city-type use.
Compact Madness! A Gallery of Small-Truck Ads
The name may read like an athlete’s-foot remedy, but the PRO-4X is the Frontier representative to the “off-road-special” caucus within the pickup market. It comes with specific 16-inch machine-finish alloy wheels; white-letter all-terrain tires; a locking rear differential; Bilstein high-pressure off-road shock absorbers; and skid plates to shield the undersides of the oil pan, fuel tank, and transfer case. Visual distinctions come down to white-faced gauges ringed in satin-chrome accents and “tire-tread” graphics on the sides of the 5-foot cargo bed. Ride isn’t too bad for this type of truck. In commuting, it came across as a little jittery at highway speeds, but not badly damped, and road cracks and joints didn’t upset it too much. Steering is pretty easy, too. Even for its age, this is not a truck you have to manhandle to get it to do anything.
Quick Spin: 2020 Ford Ranger Lariat SuperCrew
Passenger space up front is pretty good and the seats are comfy. The rear seat has less legroom than you might expect from a crew cab (yes, it’s a compact, but still . . .), and the seat back is kind of upright and not lushly padded. Three friendly adults might be able to occupy the rear seat—an almost flat floor helps—but the middle passenger ought to wear a hardhat because the dome light is directly above. Windows are big, so the driver enjoys excellent vision all around.
The selector dial for driveline settings is within easy reach of the driver’s right hand low on the instrument panel. Convenient dials are used to set temperatures for the PRO-4X’s standard dual-zone climate system; all else is managed by buttons clustered in between them. Outboard passengers have an A- or B-pillar handgrip for when terrain might get rough and bumpy, or to assist entry because step-in is a little high.
Quick Spin: 2020 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro
A big glove-box lid belies a narrow box behind it. There’s not much space in the console box, and the only seat-back pouch is on the back of the driver’s seat. There is a pull-down central armrest in back, but cup holders pop out of the back of the console. All four doors have decent storage pockets with bottle holders. Rear seat backs fold flat, and the cushions fold up to reveal storage bins.
In terms of features and appointments, the Frontier is pretty basic. Hard plastic is everywhere, and little effort is made to hide the fact that it’s plastic. The only soft stuff is on the seats, steering-wheel and shifter wraps, console-box lid, and as little of the door armrests as Nissan could get away with. Displays for things like the climate-system temperature readouts and odometer are old-school stick-figure numerals on a lighted orange background. The touchscreen for audio and navigation is small, and controls are simple. Menus? This is a compact pickup truck, not a restaurant. The tailgate is not damped—let it go and it just drops with a clunk.
Despite its cost, perhaps this is appropriate for the PRO-4X’s image. It is supposed to be the model for rugged, outdoorsy Nissan buyers whose idea of a good time is jeux avec Frontières (you’re welcome, Peter Gabriel fans). Oddly, then, there is some charm in all this—and it will probably disappear when an all-new model comes around.
Forgotten Concept: Nissan Alpha-T
Check out the Consumer Guide Car Stuff Podcast
2020 Nissan Frontier PRO-4X Crew Cab Gallery
