Oct
04

 

I didn’t see it coming, it just happened. I stepped out of one $70,000 car, and stepped directly into another.

As an auto writer, that coincidence alone does not qualify as amazing. Also not surprising is that fact that these two cars are vying for the same shoppers, more or less.

No, what’s worth noting is that one of these cars is a Cadillac, and the other a Hyundai.

To put some perspective on how far these brands have traveled to reach this strange and wonderful point in history, think back 25 years.

A quarter century ago the largest Cadillac sedan was the barge-like Brougham, a lumbering land yacht powered by a carbureted 170-horsepower 5.0-liter V8. At 221 inches long, the Brougham stretched a solid five feet beyond the rear bumper of Hyundai’s largest (and only) contemporary sedan, the Excel. The Brougham started at $25,699.

And, what of Hyundai? Still very much an economy brand, Hyundai was better known for innovative rebates (trade in any car for a guaranteed $1500) than for building anything worth driving. Powered by a 68-horsepower 1.5-liter engine, the maker’s compact Excel could lay claim to being thrifty with fuel, and pretty much nothing else. Excel prices started at $5499.

Books could be written about what happened to these two brands in the past two and a half decades, but suffice it to say, things got better for both of them. Cadillac’s largest sedan is now better suited for the Autobahn than trolling between Miami bingo halls, and Hyundai’s most impressive four-door is now a viable option for folks looking for an alternative to flagship German luxury sedans, not first-time shoppers trying desperately to get financed.

But seriously, $70,000? Yes, seriously. Keep in mind, these loaded-up examples represent everything these models have to offer. In both cases, decently equipped lesser versions can be had for fully $20,000 less.

And how do they stack up against each other? Let’s have a look:

 

                2014 Cadillac XTS Vsport                        2014 Hyundai Equus Ultimate

 

Price:                          $71,015                                                     $68,920

Engine:                       3.6-liter twin-turbo V6                                5.0-liter V8

Horsepower                410                                                            429

Drive:                          All-wheel Drive                                         Rear-wheel Drive

Wheelbase                112-inches                                                 120-inches

Length                       202 inches                                                 203 inches

Curb weight               4437 lbs.                                                   4555 lbs.

EPA fuel econ.          16/24 city/highway                                    15/23 city/highway

 

Power                                    Tie

Instrumented testing by enthusiast magazines has both of these muscle-bound sedans reaching 60 mph from a stop in just over five seconds. Credit the Equus for its immediate power delivery, delivering old-school big-block style torque just off idle.

Handling                              Equus

Folks familiar with the Cadillac DeVille DTS need only imaging that car on steroids to understand how the XTS feels when the road gets twisty. The big Caddy enjoys ample grip, but leans significantly in corners and on off ramps. On the plus side, the steering is tighter and better connected-feeling than any DeVille’s ever was, and the brakes do a nice job hauling this big rig down. The Equus, on the other hand, handles more like the big German sedans it’s meant to feel like. The big Hyundai is much easier to control when the road starts to bend, and there’s little lean in anything less than very aggressive driving. Note: The XTS Vsport comes standard with AWD—always handy in snowy climes.

Ride                                        XTS

This one isn’t even close. Hyundai has struggled trying to strike the perfect ride and handling balance on its big rear-drive sedans, and though much improved for 2014, the Equus is no match for the ultra-refined XTS. Road imperfections that result in a startling crash in the Equus register with  just a muted thud in the XTS. At speed, the Cadillac rivals Germany’s best for ride comfort.

Cabin Appointments         XTS

The Equus is very nice inside, but the XTS is ridiculous—in the best possible way. Cadillac’s new design credo seems to be to take cabin appointments 10 percent over the top, and apologize to no one for the lavishness. Some shoppers may find the XTS interior overdone, but it’s hard to argue with the obvious top-notch quality of the materials and artisan-like workmanship. The Equus cabin is by no means stark, but seems to pay homage to the restrained sterility of recent-generation big BMWs rather than the clubby wood and leather look now popular. The Equus is nice, the Cadillac fabulous.

Styling                                   Equus

I’ll just fess up now, I think the XTS looks wonky. Unlike the lean, purposeful 2014 CTS now hitting the road, the XTS looks to me as if the headlights are on the wrong end of the car. Hyundai is still playing it safe with the Equus, going with fairly anonymous lines and committing to personality only up front, where the big grille stands laden with shiny bits.

Overall                                  XTS

All told, despite their similar size, power ratings, and pricing, the Cadillac XTS Vsport and the Equus Ultimate are very different animals. The Cadillac, it seems, is trying to be the best-ever DeVille, while the Equus wants to be what the BMW 7-Series was before it became a lightning-fast rolling electronics store.

In both cases, job well done. For me, I’ll take the Equus. But, that’s just for me. I appreciate the understated simplicity of the Equus, especially its simple, robust, old-school big V8.

That said, the Cadillac seems to offer more for the money. It rides better, looks nicer inside, and should return better real-world fuel economy. However, shoppers looking for real-luxury with a dose of anonymity wont go wrong with the Equus.

Both cars, it should be noted, offering power and performance unthinkable from either make just a generation ago—all for $30,000-to-$40,000 less than the price of a BMW 7-Series.

Click here to read our review of the all-new 2014 Cadillac CTS sedan.

Vehicle Makes

Classic Cars

Collectible Automobile Magazine

Popular Posts & Pages

Recent Posts

Shopping for a new or used car or truck?

Check out all of our reviews here.